Skip to main content

Main Sub Nav

  • Prospective Students
  • Current Students
  • Faculty/Staff
  • Alumni
  • Employers
Home
  • About
    • About The School of Art
      • About
      • History
      • Mission
      • Solidarity & Justice
      • Contact Us
      • Visit the School
    • People
      • Directory
      • Lamar Dodd Professorial Chair
      • Visiting Artist & Scholar Lectures
      • Board of Advisors
      • Careers at Dodd
    • Facilities
      • Studios & Facilities
      • Art Library
      • Reserve A Space
      • The CAVE
      • Maps & Floor Plans
  • Programs
    • Undergraduate Programs
      • Overview
      • Undergraduate Admissions
      • Degree Options
      • Minors in Art & Art History
      • Studio Art Core
      • Courses
    • Graduate Programs
      • Overview
      • MA
      • MFA
      • MAEd
      • Admissions
      • PhD in Art with Emphasis in Art Education
      • PhD in Art with Emphasis in Art History
      • EdS in Art Education
      • Art Education Certificate Only Program
      • Funding & Research Support
      • Courses
    • Study Abroad & Field Study
      • Overview
      • Cortona
      • NYC Maymester Program
    • Community Programs
      • UGA Community Art School
      • UGA Summer Art Camp
      • Athens Art Book Fair
  • Events & Exhibitions
    • Speaker Series
      • Lecture Series
    • Calendars
      • Upcoming Events
      • Calendar View
      • Submit Events
      • Events Archive
    • Galleries
      • Dodd Galleries
      • Athenaeum
      • Online Exhibitions
      • Current Exhibitions
      • Upcoming Exhibitions
      • Past Exhibitions
      • Performances & Talks
      • Propose an Exhibition
  • Research
    • Programs
      • Art & Education for Social Justice Symposium
      • The Willson Center for Humanities & Arts
      • a2ru
      • Social Ecology Lab
      • UGA Arts Collaborative
      • Margie E West Award
    • Events & Galleries
      • Visiting Artist & Scholar Lectures
      • Research Days
      • Dodd Galleries
      • The Athenaeum
    • Research & People
      • Lamar Dodd Professional Chair
      • Dodd Interdisciplinary Fellows
      • Graduate Research
  • News
    • All News
    • Student News
    • Graduate News
    • Faculty & Staff News
    • Alumni News
    • Submit News
  • Give
  • Mobile Menu Extras
    • News
    • Events
    • Give

    Search form

    social_media

Taylor Swift and the Philosophy of Re-recording | Brandon Polite

UGA Humanities Festival
Fearless (Taylor's Version) Album Cover Image
Event Date
March 17, 2023 2:00 pm - March 17, 2023 3:00 pm
Add to Calendar 2023-03-17 14:00:00 2023-03-17 15:00:00 Taylor Swift and the Philosophy of Re-recording | Brandon Polite Artwork: Fearless (Taylor's Version) album cover   Taylor Swift and the Philosophy of Re-recording When Taylor Swift’s record label was sold in 2019, the six studio albums she’d recorded for them came under the control of a person with whom she has had years of bad blood: Kanye West’s former manager Scooter Braun. But rather than just shake it off and move on, Swift has taken the unprecedented step of re-recording near-duplicate versions of those albums. With all of the profits made from selling, streaming, and licensing these “Taylor’s Versions” going directly to Swift, she could deprive Braun of potentially hundreds of millions of dollars. The gambit has already paid off. The first two “Taylor’s Versions” (of Fearless and Red) debuted at Number 1 on the Billboard charts and have sold over one million copies so far; and four more are still on the way. One question that Swift’s project raises is whether she is creating new works of art that are distinct from the originals. There are at least two arguments for denying that they’re distinct works of art. The first appeals to the fact that the two versions of each album sound so similar that listeners often need to pay careful attention to notice the differences between them. From this it concludes that, similar to how a person copying out War and Peace by hand would produce a genuine instance of Tolstoy’s novel, Swift has merely produced instances of the original albums by re-recording them. This is the formalist argument. The second argument appeals to the fact that Swift intends to subtly improve on the originals when re-recording them. From this it concludes that, similar to how Tolstoy’s drafts were War and Peace at earlier stages in its development, Swift’s original recordings are actually unfinished earlier stages of the Taylor’s Versions. This is the intentionalist argument. In this presentation, Polite will defend the claim that Taylor’s versions are new works of art distinct from the original recordings against these two arguments. In doing so, Polite will untangle some of the thorny metaphysical issues that Swift’s project raises.   About the Speaker Brandon Polite is an associate professor and chair of philosophy at Knox College. Polite is also the host of the YouTube series Philosophers Discussing Art. Most of his research is in aesthetics and the philosophy of music, with an emphasis on musical representation and musical experience.   This event is presented by the Department of Philosophy, the Hugh Hodgson School of Music, the Lamar Dodd School of Art, the Willson Center for Humanities and Arts, and the UGA Humanities Council as part of the UGA Humanities Festival. Peabody Hall | Room 115 LAMAR DODD SCHOOL OF ART doddcomm@uga.edu America/New_York public
Location
Peabody Hall | Room 115
Log in to post comments
Speaker Name
Brandon Polite
Department
Philosophy
University or Organization
Knox College
Speaker's Website
Faculty Profile
Artwork: Fearless (Taylor's Version) album cover
 
Taylor Swift and the Philosophy of Re-recording

When Taylor Swift’s record label was sold in 2019, the six studio albums she’d recorded for them came under the control of a person with whom she has had years of bad blood: Kanye West’s former manager Scooter Braun. But rather than just shake it off and move on, Swift has taken the unprecedented step of re-recording near-duplicate versions of those albums. With all of the profits made from selling, streaming, and licensing these “Taylor’s Versions” going directly to Swift, she could deprive Braun of potentially hundreds of millions of dollars. The gambit has already paid off. The first two “Taylor’s Versions” (of Fearless and Red) debuted at Number 1 on the Billboard charts and have sold over one million copies so far; and four more are still on the way.

One question that Swift’s project raises is whether she is creating new works of art that are distinct from the originals. There are at least two arguments for denying that they’re distinct works of art. The first appeals to the fact that the two versions of each album sound so similar that listeners often need to pay careful attention to notice the differences between them. From this it concludes that, similar to how a person copying out War and Peace by hand would produce a genuine instance of Tolstoy’s novel, Swift has merely produced instances of the original albums by re-recording them. This is the formalist argument. The second argument appeals to the fact that Swift intends to subtly improve on the originals when re-recording them. From this it concludes that, similar to how Tolstoy’s drafts were War and Peace at earlier stages in its development, Swift’s original recordings are actually unfinished earlier stages of the Taylor’s Versions. This is the intentionalist argument.

In this presentation, Polite will defend the claim that Taylor’s versions are new works of art distinct from the original recordings against these two arguments. In doing so, Polite will untangle some of the thorny metaphysical issues that Swift’s project raises.

 

About the Speaker

Brandon Polite is an associate professor and chair of philosophy at Knox College. Polite is also the host of the YouTube series Philosophers Discussing Art. Most of his research is in aesthetics and the philosophy of music, with an emphasis on musical representation and musical experience.

 

This event is presented by the Department of Philosophy, the Hugh Hodgson School of Music, the Lamar Dodd School of Art, the Willson Center for Humanities and Arts, and the UGA Humanities Council as part of the UGA Humanities Festival.

Sponsor
UGA Department of Philosophy, the Hugh Hodgson School of Music, the Lamar Dodd School of Art, the Willson Center for Humanities & Arts, and the UGA Humanities Council
Type of Event
Lectures

Upcoming Events

View Full Calendar
  • 2025 Athens Art Book Fair

    June 21, 2025 11:00 pm

Footer Menu 1

  • Academics
  • UNDERGRADUATE PROGRAMS
  • Degree Options
  • Studio Art Core
  • GRADUATE PROGRAMS
    • MA
    • MFA
    • MAEd
    • PhD Art Education
    • PhD Art History
    • Funding & Research Support
  • Admissions
  • Studies Abroad & Field Study

Footer Menu 2

  • Galleries
    • Current Exhibitons
    • Past Exhibitions
    • Performances & Talks
    • Propose an Exhibitions
    • BFA Exhibition Guidelines

Footer Meun 4

  • Faculty & Staff
    • Faculty & Staff Resources
    • Curriculum Policies
    • Forms & Links
    • Dodd Studio Support
  • Graduate Students
  • Alumni
    • Create an Alumni Profile
    • Alumni Opportunities

Footer 3

  • Dodd Resources
  • Equipment Checkout
    • Open Access Fabrication Labs
    • Dodd Studio Support
  • Student Resources
    • Scholarships
  • Academic Advising
    • Degree Requirements
    • Minor Requirements
    • Area Portfolio Review
    • Internship Policy & Course
  • Student Opportunities
    • Submit an Opportunity for Students

Footer Menu 5

  • Facilities
    • Request a Meeting Space
  • Studio & Classroom Spaces
    • Thomas Street Art Complex
    • Art Library
    • Open Access Fabrication Labs
    • Maps & Floor Plans
  • Research
    • Visit the School
    • Board of Visitors
    • Visiting Artists & Scholars
    • Work at the Dodd
  • View Calendar

Footer Submit Menu

  • ALL FORMS AND LINKS
  • Event/Calendar Submission
  • Instructor Override Request Form
  • Multi-Student Override Request Form
  • Website Update

Franklin_A&S-FS-CW-(1)-websize.png

Lamar Dodd School of Art
University of Georgia
270 River Road
Athens, GA 30602

706.542.1511
 

CONTACT US

Privacy Policy | © 2020 Lamar Dodd School of Art, University of Georgia. All rights reserved.

Login  |  UGA Master Calendar  |  www.uga.edu                          website feedback